Document Type : Original Article
Authors
1
Assistant Professor, Institute of Culture & Communication, Allameh Tabataba’i University, Tehran, Iran Corresponding Author Email: amirabbas.alaedini@atu.ac.irIran.
2
, MA. Student in International Trade Law, Faculty of Law and Political Science, Allameh Tabataba’i Univerity, Tehran, Iran.
10.48308/jlr.2026.242825.3016
Abstract
Abstract
Introduction
The development of digital markets and the growing use of personal data and advanced algorithms have significantly transformed traditional pricing practices. In digital markets, firms can use behavioral data and other information about users to identify their characteristics, preferences, and price sensitivity, and consequently offer different prices to different consumers. This practice, commonly referred to as personalized or algorithmic price discrimination, provides firms with a greater capacity to differentiate among consumers than traditional forms of price discrimination and, in some cases, may enable them to set individualized prices for consumers. The expansion of this practice, alongside its economic and welfare effects, has raised questions concerning the scope of competition law and the requirements of personal data protection. The importance of this issue lies partly in the fact that personalized price discrimination does not produce the same effects in all markets. Under certain conditions, offering prices according to consumer characteristics may increase competition, create greater price variety, and potentially improve consumer welfare. In contrast, in concentrated or monopolistic markets, extensive access to personal data may enable firms to exploit consumers more effectively, strengthen market power, and reduce transparency. At the same time, personalized pricing generally requires the processing of personal data and therefore raises questions under data protection law, particularly concerning the lawfulness of processing, transparency, and user consent. Against this background, this study examines the economic and legal dimensions of personalized price discrimination to determine under what circumstances this pricing practice may raise concerns under competition law and personal data protection law in the European Union.
Methods
This study adopts a descriptive-analytical method and draws on economic and legal studies as well as relevant case studies concerning online markets. It first examines the concept of price discrimination, its principal forms, and the conditions required for its implementation. It then focuses on the specific characteristics of algorithmic personalized price discrimination, including the role of personal data, algorithms, and the ability of firms to differentiate among consumers. Subsequently, the study examines the effects of price discrimination under different market structures, with particular attention to competition, consumer welfare, market power, and distributive considerations. The practice is then analyzed within the framework of European Union competition law, including its potential relationship with the rules concerning abuse of a dominant position and other competition concerns. The study also considers personalized price discrimination from the perspective of personal data protection law, focusing on the requirements governing data processing, consent, and transparency. Finally, the economic and legal findings are combined to examine the possibility of adopting a multidimensional approach to the assessment and regulation of this practice.
Results and Discussions
The findings indicate that the effects of algorithmic price discrimination cannot be assessed independently of market structure and firms’ access to consumer data. In relatively competitive markets, personalized pricing can enable firms to offer a wider range of prices and, under certain conditions, may contribute to increased competition and consumer welfare. The same mechanism may nevertheless produce different consequences in concentrated or monopolistic markets. Greater access by dominant firms to consumers’ behavioral data can enable them to estimate consumers’ willingness to pay more accurately and extract a greater portion of consumer surplus. Consequently, the risks of consumer exploitation and strengthened market power may increase. From the perspective of European Union competition law, one of the main challenges is that personalized price discrimination, unlike many traditional forms of discriminatory conduct, is applied directly to final consumers and does not necessarily correspond to established patterns of anticompetitive behavior. Accordingly, the mere fact that different consumers are offered different prices is not, by itself, sufficient to justify competition law intervention. The legal assessment should take into account the structure of the relevant market, the firm’s degree of market power, the nature of the product or service, the intensity of competition, and the actual or potential effects of the conduct on the market. At the same time, where algorithmic price discrimination results in harm to competition, consolidation of a dominant position, or barriers to entry of competitors, it may become relevant under the rules governing abuse of dominance. A case-by-case assessment that takes the particular circumstances of each market into account is therefore important in evaluating this pricing practice. The economic analysis also indicates that price discrimination cannot be regarded as inherently anticompetitive or welfare-enhancing. Its effects depend on the way in which data are used, the structure of the market, and the degree of market power held by the firm. A general prohibition of all forms of personalized pricing may therefore conflict with its potentially beneficial effects in certain markets, while ignoring its risks in concentrated markets may contribute to increased market power and consumer exploitation. From the perspective of personal data protection law, personalized pricing generally involves the collection, processing, and analysis of information concerning users. Such information may include search and purchase histories, users’ behavior on websites, location information, cookies and other online identifiers, and behavioral patterns. Personalized pricing may therefore fall within the scope of personal data protection rules. Under the European Union data protection framework, firms must have a lawful basis for processing personal data and provide users with clear and accessible information concerning the purposes and manner of processing. In cases where consent constitutes the legal basis for processing, informed consent assumes particular importance, since consumers may not agree to the use of their personal data for individualized pricing. The use of cookies and similar technologies may also trigger specific requirements concerning user consent. Transparency requirements may also affect the effectiveness of personalized price discrimination itself. When consumers become aware of personalized pricing and the ways in which their data are used, they may respond by restricting firms’ access to personal data, using anti-tracking tools, deliberately altering their behavioral patterns, or adopting other similar measures. These responses may reduce the ability of algorithms to identify consumers’ characteristics accurately. Data protection therefore concerns not only the lawfulness of information processing but may also indirectly affect the ability of firms to implement personalized pricing models effectively.
Conclusion
Personalized price discrimination is an emerging phenomenon in the digital economy that connects the use of personal data and algorithms with pricing decisions. The findings of this study indicate that its effects depend on market conditions and the manner in which data are accessed and used, and therefore cannot be assessed solely by reference to the concept of price discrimination. From the perspective of competition law, particular attention should be paid to the effects of the practice on competition, market power, and the conditions of entry for competitors. From the perspective of data protection law, the lawfulness of processing, transparency, and informed consent are particularly important. Accordingly, the regulation of algorithmic personalized price discrimination requires a multidimensional approach that considers economic efficiency, competition, consumer welfare, and distributive concerns alongside the protection of personal data.
Highlights
Highlights
· The effects of algorithmic price discrimination depend on market structure and access to data, and may, depending on the circumstances, produce both pro-competitive and welfare-enhancing effects as well as exploitative effects
· Under European Union competition law, personalized price discrimination does not yet fully correspond to traditional patterns of abuse of a dominant position; however, where it disrupts competition or reinforces market power, it may become subject to competition law intervention.
· The use of personal data for personalized pricing requires compliance with data protection requirements, particularly lawfulness, transparency, and informed consent, while regulating this phenomenon requires simultaneous consideration of competition, welfare, distributive justice, and data protection.
Keywords
Subjects