Legal Research Quarterly

Legal Research Quarterly

The Agency of Legal Academics under Conditions of Institutional Disequilibrium

Document Type : Original Article

Author
Associate Professor, Faculty of Law, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran. Corresponding Author Email: shahbazinia@modares.ac.ir
10.48308/jlr.2026.243855.3048
Abstract
Abstract
Introduction
This article examines the role and patterns of engagement of legal academics when a gap emerges between legal rules, institutional performance, and social expectations. It uses the concept of “institutional disequilibrium” to describe a situation in which legal rules and formal institutions continue to exist, but their capacity to stabilize legal meaning, absorb interpretive disagreements, and channel disputes through established legal processes is weakened. By contrast, “institutional equilibrium” is treated not as an ideal condition, but as an analytical reference point in which legal rules remain reasonably predictable, institutional roles are relatively stable, and disagreements are largely managed through existing legal mechanisms. The central problem concerns how academic legal action changes when the institutional environment moves from relative equilibrium toward disequilibrium. Conduct that appears purely educational, scholarly, or interpretive under equilibrium may acquire broader public and institutional significance under disequilibrium. Teaching, doctrinal interpretation, silence, or public criticism may therefore be understood differently across institutional contexts. The main question is how institutional disequilibrium changes the meaning and consequences of legal academics’ teaching, research, interpretation, and public engagement, and what patterns of academic legal engagement can be identified in response. The article does not prescribe political positions or offer prior moral judgments; rather, it explains the relationship between institutional context, professional action, and legal and public consequences.
Methods
The study adopts a theoretical, analytical, and institution-centered methodology based on conceptual analysis and comparison between institutional equilibrium and disequilibrium. First, equilibrium is reconstructed as the analytical reference condition, with emphasis on stable professional roles, predictable legal rules, and the capacity of institutions to absorb social and interpretive tensions. Disequilibrium is then conceptualized as a weakening of the alignment among legal rules, institutional implementation, and social expectations. The concept is distinguished from related notions such as the state of exception, legitimation crisis, rule-of-law erosion, and democratic backsliding. Institutional disequilibrium does not necessarily presuppose the suspension of ordinary law, a complete crisis of political legitimacy, or regression from a consolidated democratic order. Its focus is the weakening of institutional capacity to stabilize legal meaning and manage interpretive conflict. The analysis then considers how changing institutional conditions affect legal knowledge, especially the partial shift of the burden of stabilizing meaning from institutions to knowledge actors and the weakening of the boundary between legal expertise and the public sphere. On this basis, the article identifies different patterns of academic legal engagement and examines their institutional consequences. It draws on public-law scholarship, rule-of-law theory, institutional analysis, and studies of legal and institutional erosion. These materials support conceptual differentiation and explanation of institutional mechanisms rather than an independent literature review.
Results and Discussions
The first finding is that institutional disequilibrium changes the meaning of legal action itself. Under equilibrium, teaching, research, and doctrinal debate generally remain within the recognizable boundaries of the legal academic’s professional role, while values such as the rule of law and fundamental rights are largely mediated through formal institutions. Once institutions lose part of this capacity, however, the same activities may be interpreted differently. Silence, technical teaching, doctrinal interpretation, or criticism of a public decision may, regardless of the scholar’s intention, be read as endorsement, distancing, legitimization, or criticism of the existing institutional order. Academic legal engagement therefore cannot be assessed adequately without reference to its institutional context. The second finding concerns the partial transfer of the “burden of meaning” from institutions to knowledge actors. When legal institutions become less capable of organizing competing interpretations and containing interpretive conflict, the interpretive weight of professional actors increases. Universities and legal academics may then become important sites for reproducing legal standards and clarifying limits on public power. This does not mean that individuals replace institutions; rather, weakened mediating institutions make their interpretive and public responsibilities more visible. The third finding is the weakening of the conventional boundary between legal expertise and the public sphere. Under disequilibrium, technical legal discourse is more readily interpreted within wider public controversies, while political, security-oriented, moral, or efficiency-based rationales may themselves be reformulated in legal language. Legal form therefore does not necessarily preserve law’s limiting function. Concepts such as proportionality, necessity, emergency powers, or standards of review may formally remain in place while gradually losing elements of their internal structure and constraining function.On this basis, the article identifies four principal patterns of academic legal engagement. The first is “professional minimalism,” in which legal academics concentrate on teaching existing rules, explaining established concepts, and conducting specialized research. Under equilibrium, this may constitute a legitimate academic division of labor; under disequilibrium, disregard for institutional context may inadvertently contribute to the normalization of problematic developments.The second pattern is “expert public engagement.” Legal academics use professional knowledge to explain public legal issues, clarify the consequences of competing interpretations, and identify legal limits on public authority without reducing their academic role to political advocacy. Its central feature is the translation of legal expertise into publicly accessible reasoning while preserving analytical independence. The third pattern is “doctrinal reconstruction,” which seeks to preserve the internal coherence of legal concepts and rules by reconstructing their conditions of application, limits, exceptions, and relationship to fundamental principles. It aims to prevent legal concepts from gradually being emptied of their constraining functions. Yet this approach may become overly formalistic if detached from institutional context and practical consequences. The fourth pattern is the “multidimensional reconfiguration of professional engagement.” It assumes that exclusive concentration on teaching, research, doctrinal analysis, or public engagement is insufficient under disequilibrium. These dimensions must instead be consciously coordinated. Its main components include doctrinal reconstruction, argumentative accountability, problem-oriented teaching and research, expert public engagement, epistemic independence, and sustainable professional action. Within this framework, “principled engagement” is not a fixed behavioral formula, but a way of organizing academic legal activity in light of institutional conditions while preserving the possibility of legal judgment. The responsibility of legal academics should therefore be assessed not through simple dichotomies such as silence versus intervention or professionalism versus politics, but through the relationship among action, institutional context, legal language, and institutional consequences.
Conclusion
Under conditions of institutional disequilibrium, the meaning and consequences of academic legal activity change, and apparently technical professional actions may acquire broader public and institutional effects. The central issue is not the transformation of the legal academic into a political actor, but the weakening of institutional capacities to stabilize legal meaning and the consequent transfer of part of that burden to knowledge actors. Principled engagement should therefore be understood not as a fixed model of conduct, but as a conscious reconfiguration of teaching, research, interpretation, and public engagement. Such an approach preserves epistemic independence and legal reasoning while remaining attentive to institutional consequences. Institutional analysis is thus necessary for understanding the responsibilities of legal academics and preserving law’s capacity to evaluate public power, protect fundamental rights, and serve the public interest.

Highlights

Highlights

·         The article shows that under conditions of institutional disequilibrium, changes in institutional context transform the meaning of legal academics’ teaching, research, and interpretive activities, giving them different public and institutional implications.

·         As institutions become less capable of stabilizing meaning and absorbing interpretive conflict, part of the “burden of meaning” shifts to knowledge actors; consequently, dichotomies such as silence/intervention and professionalism/politics are insufficient to explain the role of legal academics.

·         The article conceptualizes “principled engagement” not as a fixed model of conduct, but as a multidimensional reconfiguration of doctrinal reconstruction, argumentative accountability, problem-oriented teaching and research, expert public engagement, and epistemic independence.

Keywords

 
References
Books
1.        Agamben, G., State of Exception, Trans. Kevin Attell. University of Chicago Press, 2005.
2.        Dworkin, R., Law’s Empire, Harvard University Press, 1986.
3.        Dyzenhaus, D.,The Constitution of Law: Legality in a Time of Emergency, Cambridge University Press, 2006.
4.        Ginsburg, T. and Huq A. Z., How to Save a Constitutional Democracy, University of Chicago Press, 2018.
5.        Habermas, J., Legitimation Crisis. Translated by: Thomas McCarthy. Beacon Press, 1975.
6.        Hart, Herbert, The Concept of Law, Translated by: Mohammad Rasekh, Tehran: Ney Publishsing, 2011. (in Persian)
7.        Hoecke, M. V. (ed.) Methodologies of Legal Research: Which Kind of Method for What Kind of Discipline? Hart Publishing, 2011.
8.        Huscroft, G., Miller, B. W. & Webber, G. (eds.), Proportionality and the Rule of Law: Rights, Justification, Reasoning, Cambridge University Press, 2014.
9.        Jaspers, Karl, The Idea of the University, transl. H. A. T. Reiche, H. F. Vander-Schmidt. Boston: Beacon Press, 1959.
10.     Laughlin, Martin, The Idea of Public Law, Translated by: Mohammad Rasekh, Tehran: Ney Publishsing, 2009 (in Persian)
11.     Levitsky, S. and Way A., Competitive Authoritarianism, Cambridge University Press, 2010.
12.     Post, R., Democracy, Expertise, and Academic Freedom, Yale University Press, 2012.
13.     Schmitt, C., Political Theology, Four Chapters on the Concept of Sovereignty, George Schwab (trans.), Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2005.
14.     Shapiro, M. Courts: A Comparative and Political Analysis. University of Chicago Press, 1986.
15.     Shklar, J. N., Legalism: Law, Morals, and Political Trials, Harvard University Press, 1964.
Articles
16.     Bernstein, R. B., “The Law Professor as Public Intellectual”, Touro Law Review, Vol. 39, Issue 3, 2024, pp. 796–803.
17.     Carothers T.,” The End of the Transition Paradigm”, Journal of Democracy, Vol. 13, Issue 1, 2002. pp. 5–21.
18.     Green, L., “Positivism and the inseparability of law and morals”, New York University Law Review, Vol. 83, Issue 4, 2008, pp. 1035–1058.
19.     Habermas, J., “Political Communication in Media Society: Does Democracy Still Enjoy an Epistemic Dimension? The Impact of Normative Theory on Empirical Research”, Communication Theory, Vol. 16, Issue 4, 2006, pp. 411–426. DOI: 10.1111/j.1468-2885.2006.00280.x/
20.     Hart, H. L. A., “Positivism and the separation of law and morals”, Harvard Law Review, Vol. 71, Issue 4, 1958, pp. 593–629. DOI: 10.2307/1338225/
21.     Hutchinson T. and Duncan N., “Defining and Describing What We Do: Doctrinal Legal Research” Deakin Law Review, Vol. 17, Issue 1, 2012, pp. 83–119. DOI: 10.21153/dlr2012vol17no1art70/
22.     Jackson, V. C., “Knowledge Institutions in Constitutional Democracies: Preliminary Reflections”, Canadian Journal of Comparative and Contemporary Law, Vol. 7, 2021, pp. 156–221.
23.     Jardina A. and Mickey R., “White Racial Solidarity and Opposition to American Democracy”, The Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, Vol. 699, Issue 1, 2022, pp. 79–89. DOI: 10.1177/00027162211069730/
24.     Landau D. “Abusive Constitutionalism”, University of California, Davis Law Review, Vol. 47, 2013, pp. 189–259.
25.     O’Donnell G. “Delegative Democracy”, Journal of Democracy, Vol. 5, Issue 1, 1994, pp. 55–69. DOI: 10.1353/jod.1994.0010/
26.     Pech L. and Scheppele K. L., “Illiberalism Within: Rule of Law Backsliding in the EU”, Cambridge Yearbook of European Legal Studies, Vol. 19, 2017, pp. 3–47. DOI: 10.1017/cel.2017.9
27.     Scheppele K. L., “Autocratic Legalism’’, University of Chicago Law Review, Vol. 85, Issue 2, 2018, pp. 545–584. DOI: 10.2307/26455917

  • Receive Date 05 April 2026
  • Revise Date 06 June 2026
  • Accept Date 14 June 2026