Legal Research Quarterly

Legal Research Quarterly

Economic Analysis of Physician's No-Liability Rule

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
1 Professor of Law, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
2 . Assistant Professor, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran
3 Ph.D, Faculty of Law, Shahid Beheshti University, Tehran, Iran Corresponding Author Email: shokuhyan_sbu@yahoo.com
10.52547/jlr.2023.226225.2120
Abstract

Abstract
Introduction
Civil liability of physicians has undergone fundamental transformations throughout legal history. In ancient eras and the early developmental stages of medical law, the medical profession was perceived as a sacred, non-commercial, benevolent endeavor anchored in a moral bond between the healer and the patient—a perception that led to the establishment and entrenchment of the “No-Liability Rule.” Under this traditional doctrine, even in cases where physical injury or wrongful death was inflicted upon the patient during medical treatment, the physician was granted complete immunity from compensatory liability. From a Law and Economics perspective, this arrangement effectively represents an inverse application of the “Strict Liability Rule” imposed upon the victim; a regime which all accident costs and financial burdens of the harm are borne entirely by the patient. With the rapid advancement of modern biotechnology, the commercialization of healthcare delivery structures across numerous sectors, and evolving societal attitudes toward medical care, this traditional stance gradually gave way to liability regimes predicated on physician responsibility (such as fault-based liability or the presumption of fault). The central inquiry of this research is to evaluate the economic efficiency of this legal transition—specifically, whether the historical trajectory of legal systems moving from the physician’s no-liability rule toward the recognition of civil liability aligns with the criteria of economic efficiency and the minimization of total accident costs. Furthermore, this study aims to delineate the specific circumstances wherein the application of the no-liability rule retains economic justification, demonstrating cases where exempting physicians from liability remains optimal under cost-benefit analysis.
Methods
This research employs a descriptive-analytical methodology rooted in the Law and Economics paradigm, with a particular focus on the standard economic theory of tort liability developed by Steven Shavell, William Landes, and Richard Posner. The analytical framework relies on the fundamental distinction between two primary variables in accident prevention: “care level” and “activity level.” Given that patients typically cannot exercise technical intervention during surgical procedures or clinical interventions, medical treatment accidents are modeled predominantly as “unilateral accidents”—scenarios in which only the physician is capable of taking precautionary measures. Concurrently, the “activity level” of both parties (e.g., unnecessary medical visits by patients versus the volume of patient admissions and surgical interventions by physicians) is evaluated within the standard social cost minimization function of accidents. Moreover, this study draws upon core microeconomic benchmarks, including the “Cheapest Cost-Avoider” criterion, the trade-off between primary costs (precaution and accident costs) and tertiary/administrative costs (litigation and enforcement expenditures), and the utility of the doctrine of “Prospective Overruling” in mitigating institutional friction arising from sudden judicial shifts in standard-of-care thresholds.
Results and Discussions
The analytical findings of this study demonstrate that the historical transition from the no-liability regime toward physician liability is fully consistent with economic efficiency and social welfare maximization. Behavioral incentive analysis reveals that applying a blanket no-liability rule to medical services generates two severely adverse and inefficient economic consequences: First, in the absence of civil liability, the physician faces no financial incentive or deterrent mechanism to invest in elevating their “care level.” Consequently, the care level exercised by physicians plummets to zero or negligible margins, falling substantially below the “socially optimal level.” Conversely, because the social costs of high-risk procedures are not internalized, the “activity level” of physicians expands beyond optimal equilibrium, imposing unwarranted external risks on society. Second, while a no-liability rule incentivizes patients to exercise extreme caution and meticulously select their healthcare providers, patient precaution in highly specialized medical procedures is either rendered wholly ineffective due to severe asymmetric information, or the costs incurred by patients to verify a physician’s true expertise far exceed the cost of precautionary measures undertaken by medical practitioners themselves. Therefore, the physician is unequivocally the “cheapest cost-avoider,” and imposing liability on the provider is imperative to align private incentives with social care optimization. Nevertheless, specific findings indicate that despite its general inefficiency, the no-liability rule is economically justified in three exceptional circumstances: Instances where the patient is the cheapest cost-avoider: In scenarios where the cause or exacerbation of injury stems from the patient concealing medical history, non-adherence to prescribed pharmacological regimens, or failure to comply with postoperative care instructions, applying the no-liability rule properly shifts accident costs onto the patient, thereby activating optimal self-precaution incentives. Judicial transition and ambiguity in precautionary standards: When the judiciary intends to abruptly elevate the standard of care expected of medical practitioners, imposing retrospective liability on conduct that complied with the prevailing customary standards of its time is economically inefficient. Here, temporarily invoking the no-liability rule through the doctrine of prospective overruling shields the healthcare infrastructure from structural shocks, averts the proliferation of wasteful “defensive medicine,” and prevents an excessive contraction in the supply of critical healthcare services. Disproportionate administrative and litigation costs relative to social benefits: In minor, technically intricate medical malpractice disputes where the collective costs of expert testimony, negligence substantiation, and judicial proceedings outweigh the underlying economic harm, applying the no-liability rule proves more cost-effective due to the elimination of prohibitive administrative costs.
Conclusion
Ultimately, this article establishes that the “No-Liability Rule” cannot be sustained as a universal, default regime in medical law; from the standpoint of optimal resource allocation and social accident cost minimization, it is fundamentally inefficient and induces a precipitous decline in standard medical care. However, the targeted, exceptional invocation of this rule—specifically when the patient acts as the cheapest cost-avoider, during transitional phases of judicial standard refinement, and in low-stake claims burdened by disproportionate litigation costs—remains entirely congruent with economic efficiency. Consequently, legal policymakers must eschew rigid, binary frameworks by establishing fault-based liability as the general rule, while circumscribing the scope of no-liability defenses strictly to economically substantiated exceptions involving sole patient fault or high-cost patient contributory negligence.

Highlights

Highlights

1.        The physician’s no-liability rule—historically recognized based on the benevolent and non-commercial nature of medical practice—cannot be recognized as a general rule in healthcare from a Law and Economics perspective when evaluated under the twin criteria of “care level” and “activity level.”

2.        Applying the no-liability rule, distorts the incentive structure of the parties; it keeps physicians’ activity levels above the optimal threshold and their care levels below it, while potentially burdening patients with excessive self-protection efforts and costs.

3.        preserving the no-liability rule may yield economic efficiency in exceptional circumstances—such as when the patient is the least-cost avoider, where judicial standards are heightened, and where the administrative costs of litigation exceed the exemption of the physician.

Keywords
Subjects

References
Books
1.       Adib, Mohammad Hossein, Forensic Medicine, 3rd Edition., Tehran: Sahami Chehr Publishing, 1959. (In Persian)
2.       Ardabili (Muhaqqiq), Ahmad ibn Muhammad, The Collection of Utility and Proof in Explaining Irshad al-Adhhan, Volume. 10, Qom: Islamic Publishing Institute, 1993. (In Arabic)
3.       Arlen, Jennifer, Economic Analysis of Medical Malpractice Liability and Its Reform, Research Handbook on the Economics of Tort, Edward Elgar, 2013.
4.       Calabresi, Guido, The Cost of Accident: A Legal and Economic Analysis, New Haven, Ct: Yale University Press, 1970.
5.       Cooke, John, Law of Tort, 8th Edition, Longman, 2007.
6.       Cooter, Robert and Ulen, Thomas, Law and Economics, Translated by: Yadollah Dadgar and Hamedeh Akhavan Hazaweh, Tehran: Noor-e Elm Publishing, 3rd Edition., 2010. (In Persian)
7.       Dadgar, Yadollah, An Introduction to the Methodology of Economics, Tehran: Ney Publishing, 2005. (In Persian)
8.       Eyvazloo, Hossein, Justice and Efficiency in Comparison with the Islamic Economic System, Tehran: Imam Sadiq University, 2005. (In Persian)
9.       Faure, Michael, Tort Law and Economics (Encyclopedia of Law and Economics), Edward Elgar Publication, Volume.1, Second Edition , 2009.
10.    Harpwood, Vivienne, Principles of Tort Law, Cavendish, 2000.
11.    Hurr al-Amili, Muhammad ibn Hasan, Detailing the Means of the Shia to Acquiring the Issues of Sharia, Volume. 19, Qom: Ahl al-Bayt Institute for the Revival of Heritage, 1988. (In Arabic)
12.    Kakalik, James S. and Pace, Nicholas M., Cost and Compensation Paid in Tort Litigation, Santa Monica, CA: RAND Institute for Civil Justice, 1986.
13.    Makarem Shirazi, Naser, Important Jurisprudential Researches, Qom: Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib School Publications, 2001. (In Arabic)
14.    Mohaghegh Damad, Seyyed Mostafa, Rules of Jurisprudence: Civil Section 2, Tehran: SAMT Publications, 11th Edition., 2011. (In Persian)
15.    Motiei, Ensieh, Grounds for Exemption and Discharge of Physicians’ Civil Liability, Tehran: Majd Publications, 2016. (In Persian)
16.    Parisi, Francesco, The Language of Law and Economics: A Dictionary, Cambridge University Press, 2013.
17.    Pirnia, Hassan; Eqbal Ashtiani, Abbas and Behnamfar, Mohammad Hasan, The Complete History of Iran, Tehran: Farhang-e Rasa Publishing, 2nd Edition, 2010. (In Persian)
18.    Posner, Richard A., Economic Analysis of Law, New York, 1998.
19.    Salehi, Hamidreza, Civil Liability Arising from the Treatment Process, Tehran: Mizan Publishing, 2014. (In Persian)
20.    Shavell, Steven, Economic Analysis of Accident Law, Harvard University Press, 1987.
21.    Veljanovski, Cento, The Economics of Law, 2nd Edition, Great Britain, 2006.
22.    Landes, William M and Posner, Richard A, The Economic Structure of Tort Law, United State: Harvard University Press, 1987.
23.    Mathis, Klaus, Efficiency Instead of Justice? Searching for the Philosophical Foundations of the Economic Analysis of Law, New York: Springer, 2009.
24.    Thaler, Richard H., Misbehaving: The Making of Behavioral Economics, Translated by: Seyed Amir Hossein Miraboutalebi, Tehran: Donya-e Eqtesad, 2nd Edition, 2018. (In Persian)
Articles
25.    Amini, Mansour and Shokuhyan, Seyyed Alireza, “Economic Analysis of Remedies for Breach of Obligation (Specific Performance)”, Private Law Studies Quarterly, Vol. 49, Issue 1, 2019, pp.17-33. (In Persian) Doi: 10.22059/jlq.2019.256543.1007033.
26.    Badini, Hasan, “Philosophical Foundations of the Economic Approach to Law”, Journal of the Faculty of Law and Political Science, Vol. 62, Issue 512, 2003, pp.91-135. (In Persian)
27.    Becker, Selwyn W. and Brownson, Fred o., “What Price Ambiguity? Or the Role of Ambiguity In Decision-Making”, Journal of Political Economy, Vol.72, Issue 1, 1964, pp.62-73. Doi: https://doi.org/10.1086/258854
28.    Calabresi, Guido, “Optimal Deterrence and Accidents”, The Yale Law Journal, Vol.84, Issue.4, 1975, pp. 656-671. Doi: 10.2307/795387.
29.    Calabresi, Guido, “The Decision for Accident: An Approach to Non-fault Allocation of Costs”, Harvard Law Review, Vol. 78, Issue 4, 1965, pp.713-745. Doi: 10.2307/1338791   
30.    Chan, Johannes, “Disturbing the Past and Jeopardising the Future: Retrospective and Prospective Overruling”, The University of Hong Kong, 2014, pp.1-21. Doi: 10.2139/ssrn.2641354.
31.    Crider, Krista S.; Cleves, Mario A.; Reefhuis, Jennita; Berry, Robert J.; Hobbs, Charlotte and Hu, Dale J., “Antibacterial Medication Use During Pregnancy and Risk of Birth Defects”, Archives of Pediatrics and Adolescent Medicine, Vol.163, Issue 11, 2009, pp. 978-985. Doi: 10.1001/archpediatrics.2009.188.
32.    Dharmapala, Dhammika and Hoffmann, Sandra. A., “Bilateral Accident with Intrinsically Interdependent Cost of Precaution”, The Journal of Legal Studies, Vol.34, Issue 1, 2005, pp. 239-272. Doi: 10.1086/425598.
33.    Endres, Alfred and Bertram, Regina, “The Development of Care Technology under Liability Law”, International Review of Law and Economics, Vol. 26, Issue 4, 2006, pp. 503-518. Doi: 10.1016/j.irle.2007.01.004.  
34.    Feizi, Parviz and Rahimi, Bahman, “An Anthropological Study of Ritual Healing with Emphasis on the Role of Faith Healing in Kermanshah Province”,  Quarterly Journal of Medical History, Vol. 3, Issue 6, 2011, pp.97-113. (In Persian) Doi: 10.22037/mhj.v3i6.10234.
35.    Friedmann, Wolfgang, “Limits of Judicial Lawmaking and Prospective Overruling”, The Modern Law Review, Vol. 29, Issue 6, 1966, pp. 593-607.  
36.    Ghatan, Gil T., “The Incentive Problem with Prospective Overruling: A Critique of the Practice, Real Property”, Trust and Estate Law Journal, Vol.45, Issue 1, 2010, pp.179-216.
37.    Guppy, Andrew, “Subjective Probability of Accident and Apprehension in Relation to Self-Other Bias, Age and Reported Behaviour”, Accident Analysis and Prevention, Vol. 25, Issue 4, 1993, pp. 375-382. Doi: 10.1016/0001-4575(93)90067-7.  
38.    Hakimiha, Saeid, “The Trend of Criminal Legislation in Medical Affairs”, Scientific Journal of Forensic Medicine, Volume 1, Issue 4, 1995, pp.14-19. (In Persian)
39.    Khoshnoodi, Reza, “Development in the Concept of Medical Malpractice and its Instances in the French Legal System”, Medical Law Journal, Vol. 7, Issue 26, 2013, pp.41-64. (In Persian)
40.    Mehmannavaz, Mahmoud,“Investigating the Status of Superstitious Methods and Beliefs in Safavid Period Medicine”, Medical History Quarterly, Vol. 12, Issue 44, 2020, pp. 1–15. Doi: 10.22037/mhj.v12i44.30280 (In Persian)
41.    Montazeri, Saleh, and Seyyed Mohammad Ali Sadr Tabatabaei, “An Analysis of the Arguments and Foundations of Physician Immunity in Light of Jurisprudential Teachings”, Criminal Law Research Quarterly, Vol. 6, Issue 21, 2017, pp. 197–226. Doi: 10.22054/jclr.2018.12556.1219 (In Persian)
42.    Nussim, Jacob and Tabbach. Avraham D., “A Revised model of Unilateral Accident”, International Review of Law and Economics, Vol. 29, Issue 2, 2009, pp.169-177. Doi: 10.1016/j.irle.2008.05.001.
43.    Ott, Claus and Schafer, Hans-Bernd, “Negligence as Untaken Precaution, Limited Information and Efficient Standard Formation in the Civil Liability System”, International Review of Law and Economics, Vol.17, Issue 1, 1997, pp.15-29. Doi: 10.1016/S0144-8188(96)00065-8.  
44.    Posner, Richard A., “The Ethical and Political Basis of the Efficiency Norm in Common Law Adjudication”, Hofstra Law Review, Vol.8, Issue 3, 1980, pp. 487-507.
45.    Posner, Richard A., “Utilitarianism, Economics and Legal Theory”, The Journal of Legal Studies, Vol.8, Issue 1, 1979, pp.103-140. Doi: 10.1086/467603.
46.    Ramezani Ghavamabadi, Mohammad Hossein, “The Validity of the Rule of Precedent in the International Court of Justice”, Private Law Studies Quarterly, Vol. 42, Issue 1, 2012, pp.127-144. (In Persian) Doi: 10.22059/jlq.2012.29820.
47.    Salehi, Hamidreza, “The Concept of Disease and its Impact on Physicians’ Liability in Different Historical Eras”, Journal of Medical History, Vol. 5, Issue 15, 2013, pp.75-98. (In Persian) Doi: 10.22037/mhj.v5i15.5320.
48.    Shakerinia, Iraj, “Doctor-Patient Relationship and its Role in Patient Satisfaction with the Treatment Process”, Journal of Medical Ethics and History of Medicine, Vol. 2, Issue 3, 2009, pp. 9-16.(In Persian)
49.    Shavell, Steven, “Liability and the Incentive to Obtain Information about Risk”, The Journal of Legal Studies, Vol.21, Issue 2, 1992, pp. 259-270. Doi: 10.1086/467907.
50.    Shavell, Steven, “Strict Liability versus Negligence”, The Journal of Legal Studies, Vol.9, Issue 1, 1980, pp. 1-25. Doi: 10.1086/467626.  
51.    Teitelbaum, Joshua C., “A Unilateral Accident Model Under Ambiguity”, The Journal of Legal Studies, Vol. 36, Issue 2, 2007, pp. 431-477. Doi: 10.1086/511895.
52.    Weinstein, Neil D., “Optimistic Biases about Personal Risks”, Science, Vol. 246, Issue 4935, 1989, pp.1222-1233. Doi: 10.1126/science.2686031
53.    Wonnell, Christopher, “Efficiency and Conservatism”, University of San Diego School of Law, 2001, pp. 1-110. Doi: 10.2139/ssrn.285816. Available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=285816
 

  • Receive Date 26 February 2022
  • Revise Date 06 February 2023
  • Accept Date 11 July 2023