Legal Research Quarterly

Legal Research Quarterly

A Critical Study of the Offender Personality File in Iranian and English Criminal Law

Document Type : Original Article

Author
. Assistant Professor, Faculty of Law & Political Science, Islamic Azad University: Science & Research Branch, Tehran, Iran. Corresponding Author Email: docyas1366@iau.ac.ir
10.48308/jlr.2026.242176.2987
Abstract
Abstract
Introduction
Modern criminal justice, by moving away from purely punitive approaches, has shifted toward the individualization of punishment and esurance proportionality between the act committed, the offender’s personality, and the judicial response. Within this framework, the personality file functions as a practical and multidimensional institution which, by collecting data on the psychological, social, familial, economic, educational conditions, and background of the individual, plays a decisive role in achieving a more accurate understanding of the offender and analyzing the underlying causes of criminal behavior. The use of a personality file enables judges to render decisions grounded in individual and social realities, thereby preventing the issuance of uniform and generalized judgments for fundamentally different offenders. Moreover, by supporting the objectives of restorative justice, the personality file can facilitate rehabilitation, prevent recidivism, and reduce the human and social costs of the criminal justice system. The importance of this institution is not confined to the sentencing stage; rather, it may exert influence throughout all phases of criminal proceedings, from preliminary investigations to the execution of sentences and corrective and rehabilitative programs. Given the relatively recent introduction of the personality file in Iranian law and its longer-established history in England, the present study aims to conduct a comparative analysis of the status, mechanisms, and effectiveness of the personality file in the legal systems of Iran and England, and to propose solutions to strengthening this institution within Iran’s criminal justice system, in a manner that respects domestic requirements while enhancing criminal and restorative justice, and reducing recidivism.
Methods
This study adopts a descriptive–analytical method with a comparative approach. First, the theoretical foundations of modern criminal justice, the individualization of punishment, and the relationship between the personality file and the prevention of recidivism are examined. Subsequently, the legal rules and structures governing the personality file in Iran—particularly the 2013 Iranian Code of Criminal Procedure and its requirements concerning serious crimes and juvenile offenders—are analyzed, along with the practical challenges and legal ambiguities surrounding its implementation.
Results and Discussions
The findings indicate that in both legal systems, the personality file serves as an important instrument for achieving the individualization of punishment and enhancing the accuracy of judicial decision-making. However, significant differences exist in terms of institutionalization, scope of application, and supporting mechanisms. In Iranian law, the personality file was formally recognized for the first time in the 2013 Code of Criminal Procedure, and its preparation was made mandatory for certain serious crimes as well as for children and juveniles. This development reflects the legislator’s acknowledgment of the need for a more comprehensive understanding of offenders and attention to their personal characteristics during criminal proceedings. Nevertheless, in practice, the personality file faces several challenges, including the lack of uniform practice in its preparation and use, shortages of trained and specialized personnel, ambiguity regarding the scope and content of admissible information, and insufficient coordination between judicial authorities and supportive and rehabilitative institutions. Furthermore, limiting the mandatory preparation of personality files to specific cases deprives many proceedings—where the prevention of recidivism and offender rehabilitation may be achievable—of an effective tool for accurate assessment. This situation hampers the effective implementation of individualization of punishment and, at times, leads criminal justice toward standardized responses that are not necessarily proportionate to the offender’s personal and social circumstances. By contrast, the English legal system, benefiting from a longer history of utilizing offender assessment mechanisms, employs the personality file in a broader and more coherent manner throughout the criminal justice process. In this system, psychological, social, familial, and even risk-assessment evaluations regarding recidivism are typically prepared in the form of specialized reports. These reports are not confined to the sentencing stage but are utilized from early decision-making phases through sentencing, supervision of sentence execution, and rehabilitation programs. One of the key strengths of the English model lies in the structured cooperation among courts, mental health services, social services, and post-release supervision agencies. This coordinated network not only enhances the accuracy of personality file data but also facilitates the design of proportionate responses such as treatment programs, support services, alternative sanctions, and restorative measures. As a result of this integrated system, the likelihood of effective implementation of recommendations derived from personality files increases, thereby amplifying their impact on reducing recidivism. Comparative analysis demonstrates that although the legal recognition of the personality file in Iran constitutes a significant step toward modern criminal justice and restorative justice, deficiencies in executive infrastructure, institutional organization, and legal limitations hinder the full realization of its potential. In England, however, the personality file is regarded as a continuous decision-making tool, with a more prominent role in rehabilitation and the reduction of reoffending. Based on the findings, drawing upon the English experience—particularly in expanding the scope of personality files, establishing clear standards for their content and preparation, strengthening the role of multidisciplinary experts, and enhancing coordination between the judiciary and supportive and therapeutic institutions—could significantly improve the effectiveness of this institution in Iran. Moreover, the targeted use of personality files in criminal policy-making may shift judicial responses from pure punishment toward rehabilitation and restoration, thereby realizing criminal justice in its true sense, namely proportionality and individualization of punishment.
Conclusion
The present study demonstrates that the personality file constitutes one of the key pillars for achieving individualization of punishment, criminal justice, and restorative justice, and can play an effective role in reducing recidivism and enhancing rehabilitation prospects. In Iran, despite the legal recognition of the personality file in the 2013 Code of Criminal Procedure, practical challenges and legal ambiguities have prevented full utilization of its capacities. The English experience shows that institutionalizing personality files through specialized reports and inter-institutional cooperation can significantly enhance the efficiency of the criminal justice system. Accordingly, it is recommended that, while respecting domestic conditions, structural and legislative reforms, the development of expert infrastructures, and strengthened inter-agency cooperation be pursued in Iran, so that the personality file may become a more effective instrument for realizing restorative justice and reducing recidivism

Highlights

Highlights

·         A comparative analysis of the Personality File in Iranian law and the pre-sentence report in English law shows that this institution serves as a fundamental tool for achieving criminal justice and the individualization of punishment, rather than a mere procedural appendage.

·         Although the English system holds a structural advantage due to the independence of the reporting body from the prosecuting authority, the judicial practice of Iran's Supreme Court, which has overturned verdicts issued without a personality file, has created a powerful practical guarantee that even surpasses the English legislator's approach.

·         Elevating the personality file in Iran from a symbolic institution to a functional tool requires, first, a legislative revision of its scope (extending it to all Ta’ziri offenses while exempting Hudud and Qisas crimes) and, second, the establishment of a specialized, independent institution with an explicit enforcement guarantee.

Keywords
Subjects

References
Books
1.      Ashworth, A. and Rory Kelly. Sentencing and Criminal Justice, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, Fourth Edition, 2005.
2.      Gelsthorpe, L., Raynor, P., and Robinson, G., Pre-Sentence Reports in England and Wales: Changing Discourses of Need, Risk and Quality, Cullompton: Willan Publishing, First Edition, 2010.
3.      Khaleghi, Ali, Criminal Procedure Law, Volume 2, Tehran: Shahr-e Danesh, 50th Edition, 2024. (In Persian)
4.      Mehra, Nasrin, Encyclopedia of Criminal Justice in England, Tehran: Mizan, First Edition, 2019. (In Persian)
5.      Rahimian, Mitra and Morteza Zohrabi, Feasibility of Establishing a Character File in the Criminal Procedure Process, Tehran: Sanjesh and Danesh, First Edition, 2023. (In Persian)
6.      Robinson, G., and Crow, I. D., Offender Rehabilitation: Theory, Research and Practice, London: SAGE Publications, 2009.
7.      Sprack, J., A Practical Approach to Criminal Procedure, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 14th Edition, 2012.
Articles
8.      Farsi, Mahvash, Khoshroshahi, Ghodratollah Khosroshahi and Rouhollah Sepehri, “The Necessity of Establishing a Character File in Developmental Prevention of Juvenile Delinquency”, Crime Prevention Studies Quarterly, Issue 56, 2020, PP 31 – 47. (In Persian)
9.      Fattahi, Heydar and Rouhollah Sepehri, “The Impact of the Criminal Trial Process on the Formation of a Personality Case”, Legal Research Quarterly, Volume 26, Issue 102, 2023, PP 457-476. https://doi.org/10.48308/jlr.2022.229239.2358/  (In Persian)
10.  Foroutan, Reza and Sayyed Mohammadreza Emam, “A Comparative Study of the Principle of Individualization of Punishment in Islamic Criminal Jurisprudence and Iranian Law,” Comparative Criminal Jurisprudence Quarterly, Volume 1, Issue  1, 2021, PP 67-82. https://doi.org/10.22034/jccj.2022.148190/  (In Persian)
11.  Ghiasvand, Saeed, Sajedeh Mousavi, Fatemeh Zand and Mitra Basivand, “The Position of the Principle of Individualization of Punishment among the Governing Principles of Penalties,” Studies in Political Science, Law and Jurisprudence, Volume 9, Issue  3, 2023, PP 636-659. (In Persian)
12.  Goshtasbi, Mohammad, Hamidreza Aadabi and Mohammad Ali Mahdavi-Sabet, “A Comparative Analysis of the Position of the Character File in Criminal Proceedings: A Case Study of Iranian and English Law”, Journal of Comparative Studies in Jurisprudence, Law, and Politics, Volume 5m Issue  2, 2023, PP 128-144. https://doi.org/10.61838/csjlp.5.2.10/  (In Persian)
13.  Jamadi, Ali, Ramin Rostami and Jalal Bahadori, “The Character File: From the Perspective of the Legislator to Judicial Practice”, Judgment Quarterly, Volume 21, Issue 105, 2021, PP 117-139. (In Persian)
14.  Ryan, M. J., “Framing Individualized Sentencing for Politics and the Constitution,” American Criminal Law Review, Vol. 58, Issue 4, pp. 1747-1773, 2021.
15.  Sabzeh Ali, Razieh and Ghodratollah Khosroshahi, “The Role of the Personality File in Preventing Repeat Crime”, Crime Prevention Studies Quarterly, Issue 45, 2017, PP 117- 152. (In Persian)
Websites
16.  https://ara.jri.ac.ir/
17.  https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/
18.  https://www.cps.gov.uk/
19.  https://www.gov.uk/
20.  https://www.sentencingacademy.org.uk/

  • Receive Date 26 October 2025
  • Revise Date 01 December 2025
  • Accept Date 25 January 2026