1
Ph.D. Candidate of Private Law, University of Tehran
2
Assistant Professor of Law, University of Tehran
10.52547/jlr.2023.228954.2332
Abstract
Negotiation is one of the methods that seek to resolve the dispute peacefully, and legally it has an independent nature from similar methods such as arbitration, mediation and conciliation. The necessity of negotiation is that because its provisions are carried out before entering the judicial authorities, it can be an effective and efficient way to speed up the dispute resolution process and reduce the volume of cases in Iran's courts and preserve the commercial-economic information of the parties to the contract. The novelty of this topic is that the negotiation clause has not been discussed so far in relation to the effect it has on the parties and the duty of Iran’s courts in dealing with it. This research was compiled with descriptive-analytical method and using library sources and verdicts of domestic and foreign courts. The results showed that if we consider the negotiation as a clause of a passive act or a clause of the result of a partial deprivation of rights, then the guarantee of its violation will be the issuance of a non-hearing order by the court. Regarding the duty of the parties during the negotiation, it is concluded that the mere recognition of such a clause is not enough for its precise implementation, but the need for continuous cooperation and good faith on the part of the contract parties in the process of renegotiation is also required.
De Coninck B. (2002). Le droit commun de la rupture des négociations précontractuelles. In: M. Fontaine (dir.), Le processus de formation du contrat, Contributions comparatives et interdisciplinaires à l'harmonisation du droit européen, Bruylant: Bruxelles 2002, p. 17-137.
Gotenda, J. Renegotiation and Adaptation Clause in Investment Contracts, Revisited, Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, 2003; 36 (1461), pp. 1461-1473.
Grignon, P. L’obligation de ne pas agir en justice. in Mélanges Christian Mouly, Paris, Litec, 1998; vol. 2, pp: 115-130.
Guinchard, S. & Chainais, C. & Ferrand, F. Procédure civile: Droit interne et droit de l’Union européen, 2014; 32 éd. Dalloz, Paris.
Horn, N. Adaptation and Renegotiation of Contracts in International Trade and Finance, 1st edition, London: Kluwer. 1985.
Nassar, N. “Sanctity of Contracts Revisited: A study in the theory and practice of Long-Term Commercial Transactions, Dordrecht; London.1994.
Peter, W. Arbitration and Renegotiation of International Investment Agreements, second revised and enlarged edition, Kluwer law international.1995.
Rakhtyani, R. & Rohman, A. N. & Salim, A. Renegotiation in Business Contracts Due to the Covid-19 Pandemic, Nature Human Behaviour, 2022; 1 (1): 82-91.
Russi, L. Chronicles of Failure: From a Renegotiation Clause to Arbitration of Transnational Contracts, SSRN Electronic Journal, Conn. J. Int'l L. 77.2008.
Terré, F & Simler, P & Lequette, Y. Les obligations, Dalloz, Paris.2005.
مقالات:
Ancel, P. & Cottin, M. “L’efficacité procédurale des clauses de conciliation ou de mediation”, Recueil Dalloz, 2003. 1386-1391.
Ancel, P. “Force obligatoire et contenu oblligationnel du contrat”, RTD. Civ,1999: pp: 771-810.
Berger, K. “Renegotiation and Adaptation of International Investment Contracts the Role of Contract Drafters and Arbitrators”, Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law, 2003; 36: 1364.
Bernardini, P. “Stabilization and Adaptation in Oil and Gas Investments”, Journal ofWorld Energy Law & Business, 2008; 1: pp: 101-102.
Bishop, R. “The Duty to Negotiate in Good Faith and the Enforceability of Short-TermNatural Gas Clauses in Production Sharing Agreements”, CPMLP Discussion. Paper No. DP13, Dundee.1997
Kebir, M. “Clause de médiation préalable: inapplication au demandes reconventionnelles”, Actualité.2017.
Kolo, A. & Wälde, T. “Renegotiation and Contract Adaptation in the International Investment Project: Applicable Legal Principles and Industry Practices”, the Journal of Word Investment and Trade, 2003; 1 (1), pp: 1-55.
Lagarde, X (2000). “L’efficacité des clauses de conciliation ou de mediation”, arb.2000.
Ng'ambi, Sangwani Patrick (2014). “Efficient and Flexible: The Case for Renegotiation Clauses in Concession Agreements”, Zambia Law Journal, 2000; pp: 1-27.
Tijani Mato, H. (2012). “The Role of Stability and Renegotiation in Transnational Petroleum Agreements”, Joumnal of Politics and Law, University of Abuja, Nigeria, 2012; Vol 5, No 1, pp: 33-42.
رساله(ها)
Abdullah hamad, S. “Renegotiation clause in international petroleum contracts”, Master’s thesis, Neareast university, School of social science.2017.
Momberg Urbin, R. A. (2011). “The Effect of Change of Circumstances on the Force of Contracts”, PhD thesis. 2011.
پرونده(های) بینالمللی
Government of the State of Kuwait, V. the American Independent Oil Company; (1982). ad hoc Arbitrational Tribunal, 21 ILM.
Amini, A. and pilvar, R. (2023). The nature and consequences of the renegotiation clause to the court and to the parties of a contract: A comparative study. Legal Research Quarterly, 26(103), 313-336. doi: 10.52547/jlr.2023.228954.2332
MLA
Amini, A. , and pilvar, R. . "The nature and consequences of the renegotiation clause to the court and to the parties of a contract: A comparative study", Legal Research Quarterly, 26, 103, 2023, 313-336. doi: 10.52547/jlr.2023.228954.2332
HARVARD
Amini, A., pilvar, R. (2023). 'The nature and consequences of the renegotiation clause to the court and to the parties of a contract: A comparative study', Legal Research Quarterly, 26(103), pp. 313-336. doi: 10.52547/jlr.2023.228954.2332
CHICAGO
A. Amini and R. pilvar, "The nature and consequences of the renegotiation clause to the court and to the parties of a contract: A comparative study," Legal Research Quarterly, 26 103 (2023): 313-336, doi: 10.52547/jlr.2023.228954.2332
VANCOUVER
Amini, A., pilvar, R. The nature and consequences of the renegotiation clause to the court and to the parties of a contract: A comparative study. Legal Research Quarterly, 2023; 26(103): 313-336. doi: 10.52547/jlr.2023.228954.2332
)