Protecting Individual Privacy in the Metaverse: Solutions to Combat Assault and Abuse

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Assistance Professor, Faculty of law & Social Science, Payame Noor University, Tehran, Iran. m.karimi342@pnu.ac.ir

Abstract

Abstract
Introduction
The emergence of the metaverse represents a fundamental transformation in human-computer interaction. This space, which blends augmented physical reality with persistent virtual life, provides unprecedented opportunities for social relationships, commerce, education, and entertainment. However, this expansive digital realm is not without significant challenges. Among these challenges, the occurrence of sexual violence in the metaverse presents itself as an urgent and serious issue requiring immediate attention. This disturbing phenomenon exploits the very technological innovations that shape the metaverse's unique characteristics. This article undertakes two critical tasks: (1) it precisely demonstrates how the metaverse is evolving and provides an in-depth analysis of its development, and (2) it examines how certain individuals misuse these emerging technologies to commit sexual crimes. This research begins with a comprehensive evaluation of extensive studies surrounding the complex aspects of metaverse development. This evaluation encompasses the metaverse's foundational technologies, ethical challenges and issues, concerns related to user privacy and security, and legal frameworks for ensuring a safe environment and preventing criminal activities. This research seeks to identify effective legal mechanisms for mitigating sexual violence in the metaverse, recognize deficiencies in existing legislation, and offer recommendations for improving current laws.
Methods
This article employs legal methodology, library research, and descriptive analysis to comprehensively examine challenges and develop holistic solutions regarding sexual violence in the metaverse. This research primarily utilized academic sources through searches in reputable scientific databases including Google Scholar, ScienceDirect, and other authoritative databases containing legal, technological, and social science publications. Key search terms included "metaverse," "virtual world," "sexual harassment," "online harassment," and "technology law”.
Results and Discussion
The metaverse represents a revolutionary domain for social interactions that faces serious legal challenges. Current legal frameworks are inadequate for addressing the complexities of this environment, particularly concerning sexual violence and victimization. This article seeks to provide solutions for understanding the legal challenges of the metaverse, establishing a comprehensive legal framework, and maintaining user security and dignity regarding sexual crimes. The metaverse blurs the boundaries between virtual and physical reality, necessitating that legal concepts be redefined in a manner that considers the psychological and emotional impacts of virtual interactions. The role of consent mechanisms in the metaverse has emerged as a fundamental concern in sexual crimes. Developing clear protocols for obtaining explicit consent in virtual interactions is essential to protect users from unwanted experiences. This issue requires educating users about behavioral norms and etiquette in the metaverse and equipping them with interaction control tools. For example, Meta has introduced personal boundary features that allow users to manage their personal space, thereby reducing the likelihood of sexual harassment and victimization. The global nature of the metaverse creates significant jurisdictional challenges that require international cooperation and the establishment of a common legal framework. This framework must cover key issues such as consent, anonymity, and financial transactions while ensuring unified cross-border regulation. Addressing the issue of anonymity in the metaverse in relation to sexual crimes is another critical aspect that requires attention. Implementing user authentication mechanisms through real-world identifiers can reduce accountability issues but raises concerns about data protection and user privacy. Therefore, platforms must strike a balance between user identity verification and ethical management of sensitive information. In the virtual world of the metaverse, it must be clearly established what duties and responsibilities companies operating these virtual spaces bear. The first matter concerns content moderation. Platforms have a duty to monitor and control the content circulating within their virtual environments. This duty encompasses not only identifying and removing harmful content but must also be balanced with users' right to freedom of expression. The primary challenge lies in designing monitoring systems that are both effective and attentive to the nuances of user interaction in these virtual spaces. The second matter concerns the critical issue of user identity verification, which plays a vital role. Verifying users' real identities is a powerful strategy for preventing inappropriate behavior, as it links virtual actions to real-world accountability. However, implementing user authentication processes raises concerns about privacy and data protection, requiring an approach that enhances overall security while respecting user privacy. The legal liabilities of metaverse platforms primarily emerge when these duties are violated or neglected. Suppose a platform fails to properly moderate its content or verify user identities, and this negligence leads to instances of sexual harassment or abuse. In such cases, the platform may face legal and regulatory consequences. This underscores the importance of proactive and robust management by platform providers to protect users and ensure a respectful and secure virtual environment. As the metaverse continues to expand and becomes integrated into various aspects of daily life, the imperative for these platforms to embrace their responsibility in creating and maintaining safe virtual spaces becomes increasingly paramount.
Conclusion
This article emphasizes the evolving role of metaverse platforms. These platforms can no longer be regarded merely as communication intermediaries but must actively participate in content moderation and ensuring user safety against sexual victimization. This shift in responsibility necessitates that platforms develop robust monitoring systems and contribute to creating a safe virtual environment. The central argument is that regulating the metaverse is a multidimensional process requiring coordinated collaboration among legislators, technology experts, and users. The legal framework of the metaverse must be dynamic while maintaining the fundamental principles of safety, respect, and accountability. This article provides a comprehensive analysis for these efforts and presents insights and recommendations that can guide future legal and regulatory approaches in addressing sexual crimes in this emerging digital frontier

Highlights

  • This research has identified metaverse-based sexual threats and subsequently examined the psychological and social harms inflicted upon victims.
  • In This Research, the main objective, which is to enrich the discourse on the metaverse and strive to establish robust and flexible legal measures while providing a comprehensive framework for protecting individuals against sexual threats in the metaverse era, has been presented.

An effort has been made to contribute to creating supportive mechanisms against any assault on and abuse of individuals' sexual privacy

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1.  

    Articles

    1. Blackwell, Lindsay, Nicole Ellison, Natasha Elliott-Deflo and Raz Schwartz. “Harassment in Social Virtual Reality: Challenges for Platform Governance”, Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, Volume 3, Issue CSCW, 2019, PP 1-27. https://doi.org/10.1145/3359202
    2. Cripps, Jenna and Lana Stermac. “Cyber-Sexual Violence and Negative Emotional States among Women in a Canadian University”, International Journal of Cyber Criminology, Volume 12, Issue 1, 2018, PP 171-186. Doi:10.5281/zenodo.1467891
    3. Freeman, Guo, Samaneh Zamanifard, Divine Maloney and Dane Acena. “Disturbing the Peace: Experiencing and Mitigating Emerging Harassment in Social Virtual Reality”, Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction, Volume 3, Issue CSCW, 2022, PP 1-30. Doi:10.1145/3512932
    4. Gonzalez-Franco, Mar, Anthony Steed, Steve Hoogendyk and Eyal Ofek. “Using Facial Animation to Increase the Enfacement Illusion and Avatar Self-Identification”, IEEE Transactions on Visualization and Computer Graphics, Volume 26, Issue 5, 2023. Doi: 10.1109/TVCG.2020.2973075
    5. Hakim-Pour, Yasamin, “From Algorithms to Deep Learning: What We Need to Know About Artificial Intelligence”, AuditorJournal, Issue 123, 2023, PP 70-73. (in Persian)
    6. Hassan-Zadeh, Mohammad and Sayyed Mehdi Hosseini, “Web Accessibility: Concepts and Applications”, Rahyaft Journal, Volume 20, Issue 46, 2010, PP 33-44. Doi: 20.1001.1.10272690.1389.20.46.3.4 (in Persian)
    7. Heidari, Ali Morad and Ali Ja’fari, “Criminal Protection of Audio-Visual Media in Iranian Law”, Media Quartrly, Volume 21, Issue 2, 2010, PP 87-109. Doi: 20.1001.1.10227180.1389.21.2.5.1 (in Persian)
    8. Jesse, Lake. “Hey, You Stole My Avatar!: Virtual Reality and Its Risks to Identity Protection”, Emory Law Journal, Volume 69, Issue 4, 2020, PP 833-879. Available at: https://scholarlycommons.law.emory.edu/elj/vol69/iss4/5/
    9. Kalaf, Juliana, et al. “Sexual Trauma is more Strongly Associated with Tonic Immobility than other Types of Trauma-A Population based Study”, Journal of Affective Disorders, Volume 215, 2017, Doi: 10.1016/j.jad.2017.03.009
    10. King, Daniel L. et al. “Screening and Assessment Tools for Gaming Disorder: A Comprehensive Systematic Review”, Clinical Psychology Review, Volume 77, 2020. Doi: 10.1016/j.cpr.2020.101831
    11. Lee, Hyun W., Sanghoon Kim and Jun-Phil Uhm. “Social Virtual Reality (VR) Involvement Affects Depression When Social Connectedness and Self-Esteem Are Low: A Moderated Mediation on Well-Being”, Frontiers in Psychology, Volume 12, 2021. https://doi.org/3389/fpsyg.2021.753019/
    12. Lemley, Mark A. and Eugene Volokh. “Law, Virtual Reality, and Augmented Reality”, University of Pennsylvania Law Review, Volume 166, Issue 5, 2018. Doi:10.2139/ssrn.2933867
    13. Lin, Jinghuaiand Marc E. Latoschik. “Digital Body, Identity and Privacy in Social Virtual Reality: A Systematic Review”, Frontiers in Virtual Reality, Volume 3, 2022, PP 9-65. Doi:10.3389/frvir.2022.974652
    14. Lorenzo-Dus, Nuria and Cristina Izura. “Cause ur Special”: Understanding Trust and Complimenting Behaviour in Online Grooming Discourse”, Journal of Pragmatics, Volume 112, 2017, PP 68-82. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.pragma.2017.01.004   
    15. Ramirez, Erick, Shelby Jennett, Jocelyn Tan and Sydney Campbell and Raghav Gupta. “XR Embodiment and the Changing Nature of Sexual Harassment”, Societies, Volume 13, Issue 2, 2023. https://doi.org/10.3390/soc13020036
    16. Reeves, Carla. “Fantasy Depictions of Child Sexual Abuse: The Problem of Ageplay in Second Life”, Journal of Sexual Aggression, Volume 19, Issue 2, 2011, PP 75-301. Doi:10.1080/13552600.2011.640947
    17. Ryu, Riseul, Soonja Yeom, Soo K. Kim and David Herbert. “Continuous Multimodal Biometric Authentication Schemes: A Systematic Review”, IEEE Access, Volume 20, Issue 9, 2021, PP 34544-34552. Doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2017
    18. Semple, Mid, Jeffrey Hatala, Patricia Franks and Margherita A. Rossi. “Is Your Avatar Ethical? on-Line Course Tools That are Methods for Student Identity and Verification”, Journal of Educational Technology Systems, Volume 39, Issue 2, 2011. PP 181-191. Doi:10.2190/ET.39.2.h
    19. Shahriari, Hamid, “Religion, Culture and Information Technology: Benefits and Challenges of Virtual Identity in Cyberspace”, Rahavarde Noor Journal, Issue 35, 2011, PP 2-7. (in Persian)
    20. Tahmasebi, Javad and Kheirollah Shahmoradi, “Challenges and Gaps in the Process of Addressing Cybercrime”, Justice Legal Journal, Volume 82, Issue 105, 2018, PP 95-121. (in Persian)
    21. Zytko, Douglas and Jonathan Chan. “The Dating Metaverse: Why We Need to Design for Consent in Social VR”, IEEE